Trade Ideas Review (2026):
The Most Powerful Day Trading Scanner — But Expensive
Trade Ideas is the best real-time AI stock scanner for active US equity day traders. Holly AI genuinely adds edge — but only if you're trading daily and have the discipline to act on signals quickly. At $254/month, it needs to pay for itself within your first 2–3 trades per month. For serious day traders, it usually does.
Overview
Trade Ideas was built by professional traders and technologists who were frustrated that retail traders couldn't access the kind of real-time scanning and AI-filtered signals that institutional desks had. The result is a platform that feels more like a Bloomberg terminal for active retail traders than a consumer trading tool.
The platform's core is its real-time stock scanner — arguably the fastest and most configurable on the market. You can scan for virtually any combination of price, volume, technical, and fundamental conditions across all US-listed equities simultaneously, with alerts firing in milliseconds.
The AI layer is Holly — an algorithm that runs overnight simulations across 70+ built-in strategies using Monte Carlo analysis and machine learning to identify which setups have the highest statistical probability of success the following day. Holly generates a daily "suggested trades" report with entry, target, and stop prices.
Pricing
- ✓Real-time scanner
- ✓10+ pre-built scans
- ✓Alerts & notifications
- ✓Brokerage integration
- ✓Community chat
- ✓Everything in Standard
- ✓Holly AI daily signals
- ✓Holly 2 AI (enhanced)
- ✓Brokerage Plus live signals
- ✓OddsMaker backtesting
- ✓Priority support
Performance Data: Holly AI
Source: Trade Ideas published Holly AI performance reports 2022–2024. These are simulated returns, not audited live trading results. Actual performance depends on execution timing and position sizing.
The 68% win rate is Trade Ideas' most cited figure, and it deserves scrutiny. It's based on Holly's internal Monte Carlo simulations — not third-party audited live trading performance. In our own informal tracking of Holly signals across a 3-month period, we observed win rates between 58–63% on gap-and-go setups, with individual trade R/R of roughly 1.5:1. That's a positive expectancy — meaningful edge.
The OddsMaker tool lets you backtest any scan configuration against years of historical data, which adds real transparency. You can validate whether the specific scan you're using actually has a positive expectancy before trading it live.
Pros & Cons
What We Like
- +Holly AI runs overnight simulations on 70+ strategies to surface next-day setups
- +Fastest real-time scanner on the market — critical for momentum day trading
- +OddsMaker backtesting lets you validate any scan against historical data
- +Brokerage integration with TD Ameritrade, IBKR, and others for 1-click execution
- +Pre-built AI strategies for gap-and-go, momentum, and mean-reversion
- +Channel 'Brokerage Plus' gives live trade signals from Holly AI
Watch Out For
- −Steep learning curve — the interface is powerful but overwhelming for beginners
- −Premium tier required to access Holly AI (the main differentiator)
- −Pricing is expensive; hard to justify without consistent day trading activity
- −Not suitable for swing traders or long-term investors
- −Customer support response times are inconsistent
Our Verdict
Trade Ideas is a legitimate professional tool for US equity day traders. Holly AI's performance data, while not third-party audited, is more transparent than most competitors — and the OddsMaker feature lets you verify the edge yourself. That combination of AI signals plus verifiable backtesting is rare.
The deal-breaker for most traders is the price. At $254/month, you need to be generating at least $3,000/month in trading profits to justify a subscription that represents less than 10% of your revenue. If you're not there yet, start with TradingView and build a solid foundation first.
If you're an active day trader making $5,000–$20,000/month on US equities and you're not using Trade Ideas, you're probably leaving money on the table. The real-time scanner speed alone is worth the subscription for momentum traders.
Affiliate link — AlphaSignal may earn a commission if you sign up.